New paper on degrees of urbanization

New paper on degrees of urbanization

May 27, 2022

New paper titled „To be, or not to be ‘urban’? A multi-modal method for the differentiated measurement of the degree of urbanization” has been published by Taubenböck & Team.

Abstract: Today, 56.6% of the world’s population is urban and the trend is rising; in Germany, the urbanization process is almost complete at 80.3%. This is the ubiquitously used narrative. Surprisingly, the figures behind it are rarely questioned. The spatial statistics responsible for this meta-narrative are, however, prone to ambiguity. They suffer from a lack of systematic empirical justification, and from cross-national differences in cut-off values used to differentiate between urban and rural populations. In this study, we present an empirical approach that allows to systematically map urban and rural populations in a spatially and thematically differentiated manner using a multimodal method. On the one hand, we resort to the common approach of presenting the degree of urbanization in terms of population figures for administrative units. However, we do not only use the common national threshold value, but we project various national thresholds applied in different countries across the globe to classify multiple degrees of urbanization onto our study site Germany. On the other hand, we also calculate various degrees of urbanization at a higher spatial resolution using a regular grid. Beyond the common approach of calculating the degree of urbanization by population figures, we also apply at grid-level two additional variables: building density and the share of a certain building type. By systematically applying thresholds between minimum and maximum per variable, we trace the effects on the resulting degree of urbanization. These multiple perspectives lead us to propose that a range rather than a singular threshold allows us to estimate the degree of urbanization in a more differentiated way. To do so, we estimate the degree of urbanization for Germany on a probability-based basis. Therefore, we combine possible variants from the administrative approach using population figures and the grid-based approach using thresholds of population, building density and the share of a certain building type. Our results show that Germany can be considered urban by at least 50.0% up to possibly 68.1% of the population, which by no means comes near the reported 80.3%. We conclude that the results of the commonly used approach to quantify urban populations are not tenable in their clarity and should therefore be used only with great caution for political and societal decision-making.

you may also like:

New staff member Luisa Pflumm

New staff member Luisa Pflumm

Luisa Pflumm joined the Earth Observation Research Cluster in May 2024 as part of the EcoGlob project and is working with the UAS team in the context of remote sensing for biodiversity and nature conservation. She received her Bachelor's degree in Geography from the...

New team member: Ása Dögg Adalsteinsdottir

New team member: Ása Dögg Adalsteinsdottir

Ása Dögg Adalsteinsdottir joined the Earth Observation Research Cluster in May 2024 as a member of the EO4CAM project team. After earning a bachelor's degree in geography from the University of Iceland, she moved to Germany to study in our EAGLE master's program. She...

NEW TEAM MEMBER: CHRISTIAN SCHÄFER

NEW TEAM MEMBER: CHRISTIAN SCHÄFER

Christian Schäfer joined the EO4CAM project in May 2024. He received his Master's degree in 2017 from Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg (JMU), focusing on GIS-based synthesis of transboundary soil maps. During his work in the JMU BigData@Geo project, he enhanced...

GGW talk on geodata, mobility and social media

GGW talk on geodata, mobility and social media

On Monday the 13th of May our PhD students Ariane Droin and Johannes Mast were holding a talk at the Geographische Gesellschaft Würzburg organised by the Fachschaft Geographie about 'Geodaten, Mobilität und soziale Medien. Big data und die lokale Perspektive der...

NetCDA kick-off workshop

NetCDA kick-off workshop

Yesterday, on May 16th, the partners of the project "European Academic Network for Capacity Development in Climate Change Adaptations in Africa" (NetCDA) met to jointly and officially kick-off their project. The NetCDA team at the University of Würzburg invited all...